Probate is the legal process where a court proves, or validates, the decedent’s will; appoints his or her personal representative; and often oversees the collection, distribution, or sale of the decedent’s property. The probate property, that is. Thus, it is important for the practitioner to know the difference between probate and non-probate property. The easy, but unsatisfactory answer is that probate property is anything other than non-probate property. So what is non-probate property; that is, what property passes at death without a permission slip from the court?
Here’s another easy, but more instructive answer: non-probate property is property that does not pass under the decedent’s will. As the list below illustrates, that could include a lot of property:
Non-Probate Property
Property that passes by beneficiary designation, which generally includes:
- Life insurance policies (but see below),
- Annuities,
- Retirement plans (see https://www.irs.gov/retirement-plans/plan-sponsor/types-of-retirement-plans for an explanation of each of the following plans):
- Individual retirement accounts or IRAs,
- Roth IRAs,
- Employee Stock Ownership Plans or ESOPs,
- Pension Plans, including
- Defined Benefit Plans,
- Money Purchase Plans,
- 401(k) Plans,
- 403(b) Plans,
- Simple IRA Plans (Savings Incentive Match Plans for Employees),
- SEP Plans (Simplified Employee Pension),
- SARSEP Plans (Salary Reduction Simplified Employee Pension),
- Payroll Deduction IRAs,
- Profit Sharing Plans,
- Governmental Plans under 401(a),
- 457 Plans,
- 409A Nonqualified Deferred Compensation Plans,
- Payable-on-Death or POD Accounts,
- Transfer-on-Death of TOD Accounts, including investment accounts,
- Property that passes by deed, which includes:
- Real estate owned in 1. joint tenancy with rights to survivorship (JTWS), 2. life estate where property passes to another upon death of life tenant, and 3. any property the decedent held in a life estate,
- Property that passes by account designation, which includes: 1. Bank accounts owned jointly, and 2. brokerage accounts owned jointly,
- Vehicles owned jointly,
- Safety deposit boxes,
- Other property that falls within the definition of a “non-probate transfer,” including ; 1. Insurance policies, contracts of employment, bonds, mortgages, promissory notes, deposit agreements, pension plans, trust agreements, conveyances, or virtually any other written instrument effective as a contract, gift, conveyance, or trust.
- Property owned by a trustee of a trust. (Of course, if the decedent is the settlor of a trust, that trust will be subject to an administration somewhat similar to the administration that takes place in probate, but away from the prying eyes of both a judge and the public.)
Non-probate property bypasses Go, bypasses the court, and goes directly to the beneficiary, the joint account holder, the joint owner. Often the movement of the property from the decedent owner to the surviving owner is virtually seamless—well, painless anyway: beneficiaries file a death claim with the insurance company, attach a death certificate, and voila! the death proceeds appear. But often the movement requires a trip to the DMV. Even that need not be a chore. If the word “or” separated the two names on the title, the survivor doesn’t have to do anything; however, if he or she wishes to remove the decedent’s name off the title, then mailing or hand-delivering a “Vehicle Application for Title” to the DMV along with a check to cover the cost of removing the name, will do the job. If the word “and” separates the name, the survivor will also need to provide a death certificate.
Likewise, the surviving owner(s) of real property owned in a JTWS must take a few steps to terminate the decedent’s interest in the property under most states’ probate code, including filing an affidavit substantially similar to the statutory form in the county where the property is located and attaching a copy of the death certificate. (By the way, if the decedent owned real estate as a trustee of a trust, the successor trustee should file a similar affidavit along with a death certificate, indicating that the successor trustee has assumed the position of the deceased trustee with regard to the property.)
It should go without saying, but I’ll say it anyway: non-probate property will pass to the intended beneficiary, account holder, surviving owner notwithstanding what the decedent said in his or her will. In other words, the beneficiary designation, the deed, the POD/TOD, etc. controls the disposition of non-probate property, not the will.
Probate Property
If non-probate property includes everything on the list above, probate property includes everything else, including the following:
- Life insurance/annuities payable to the insured’s estate,
- Personal property—art, furniture, antiques, and the like—not jointly owned,
- Real estate the decedent owns either as an individual or as a tenant in common,
- Accounts owned individually by the decedent, including
- Bank accounts,
- Brokerage accounts,
- Etc.
- Any other property the decedent owned individually at death.
And if it’s probate property, the court will have some say about who gets what, governed by the decedent’s will of course.
The Attorney’s Job
The probate attorney’s or personal representative’s or PR’s job is to separate the non-probate wheat from the probate chaff. To do that, the attorney or PR should consult the relevant documents. That requires gathering account statements, life insurance policies, retirement plan beneficiary designations, titles, deeds, and the like to determine how the property is owned and who the beneficiaries are in the relevant cases. That may turn out to be more difficult than it seems, largely because you can’t be sure the decedent’s heirs know fact from fiction. Thus, don’t rely on the life insurance policy in the decedent’s file drawer to tell you who or what is the beneficiary. Ask the life insurance agent or call the company to get a copy of the most recent beneficiary designation. Call the title company to pull the most recent vesting deed. (You might even go further, some attorneys argue that there’s no need to record a deed to a revocable trust; thus, the most recent recorded vesting deed may not be the most recent deed.) In other words, check primary sources.